Book Log: Impossible

[penmage]

Impossible by Nancy Werlin

Lucy Scarborough doesn’t really believe in true love. She believes in being practical, in being content in her life with her beloved foster parents, Soledad and Leo Markowitz, and the friendship of guy-next-door Zach. And most of the time, she can keep her birth mother Miranda, who is insane, lives on the streets, and sometimes shows up to harass her, out of sight and out of mind. But that’s before the nightmare begins—the rape, her pregnancy—and the discovery of an ages-old curse.

Lucy is one in a long line of Scarborough women—women who get pregnant when they are seventeen, and are doomed to madness from the moment their daughter is born—unless they can complete three impossible tasks. Lucy is afraid—but she is determined to try to succeed, even though generations of Scarborough women before her have always failed. But she has something they don’t—the love of her foster parents, and the strength and courage of Zach—who is becoming more than a friend with every passing day.

This is the kind of book that I love most: a retold fairy tale that fits, doesn’t feel forced, and allows for modern influences. It reminds me of Pamela Dean’s Tam Lin—with both the implied positives and negatives of that title. I felt a little bit like the first half of the book—up until Lucy really discovers and believes in the curse—dragged. It’s unavoidable, I guess, but as the reader, I knew that the curse was true, and I was just waiting for Lucy to discover it and believe it herself. It made me impatient for the book to get moving.

But once it picked up, it certainly did get moving. Once Lucy and her family accept the reality of this crazy curse, the modern approach to solving an ancient puzzle is fascinating and compelling. There are certain moments in the book that feel a little silly—but they are mitigated because Werlin has the characters recognize that they’re silly, or that certain reactions or decisions don’t make any sense at all, but they’re making them anyway.

I also found the omnipresent feeling of dread in the book abolutely fascinating. The introduction of Padraig Seeley is chilling--even as Lucy and her supporters don't recognize the gravity of the threat, the reader does, which adds an element of urgency that, for much of the book, made me want to yell at Lucy to get moving. And once Lucy does realize just how awful things could be--the possibility of failure is absolutely chilling. Kudos to Werlin for making me utterly afraid for Lucy as the book neared it's close--and also for not ignoring the fact that even though a happily-ever-after may solve the immediate supernatural problems, there are still as many real life (though not as life-threatening) problems caused by the solution and the aftermath.

Overall, it’s a good solid read and a great contribution to the growing canon of retold modern fairy tales. As an aside, I do think it’s fascinating how retold ballads always seem to contain a pregnancy—like in Tam Lin.

Comments

[medievaloracle.livejournal.com]

I'm not sure I liked this one as much. I agree it picked up towards the end (I finished the last 150 pages in one night), but I'm not really sure I enjoyed the book as a whole. I would have liked to have seen more of Padraig Seeley, or why the nurse who works with Soledad is not affected by him when everybody else is. It only happens once, and I'd like to know more.

Also, I have a bit of an issue considering Lucy and Zach's relationship "true love". They've been friends all their lives, and when something awful happens he decides to confess his undying love and imagine her naked. Yes, he also wants to protect her, but I think he could do that just as well as a friend, and frankly, I think his timing just sucks. I know the story is about the power of love, and it wouldn't really work if they aren't "in love", but I have issues calling what I just read true love.

...And this is why I can never, ever, make it through Twilight.

[penmage.livejournal.com]

I definitly agree that it's not my favorite. I especially think that the beginning dragged like crazy, which I guess is unavoidable, but irritated me a lot.

I'm with you on the Zach thing too--his timing definitly sucks, but I think I saw from the beginning--before the rape--that he had had feelings for her for a while, and just hadn't managed to tell her. It seemed to me that while his timing was terrible, his love for her didn't just sprout from a knight in shining armor protector instinct--though there was definitly some of that in the mix as well. He loved her all along.

I think on Lucy's side, one of the things I liked was that she was reluctant to give in to loving him because she wasn't sure if she was loving him because it was convenient or because she really loved him. True love is always a tricky thing--especially in modern settings--and I think one of the things that I got from this book is that True Love is not something that comes down from on high--it's not that one person is fated to fall In True Love with another person, and that person is your True Love.

It's more that love comes from caring for each other, from making an active decision to care and give to the other person and respect each other. In Lucy and Zach's case, they were protected by love, not because their love was so magical and pure or anything, but because they were working for each other and with each other to build a love.

Does that make sense?